Hello :] So, I don’t have the black now, I just want you to know. I gave it to my sister when she visited and forgot her makeup. Anyway, I bought this at Big Lots for either $1-$2 and thought it was really good because these pencils are really long and will last a long time. I was super excited for the plum but it … Continue reading Review: Pro-Professional eyeliner in Black, Plum, and Brown