Hello Shopahaulics, Tiffany here, and I will say that this eyeliner is pretty great. I love the consistency when it is applied and the pigmentation is great. Out of the eyeliners, this is the only one that I own, so I cannot vouch for the other colors. I wanted a green liquid eyeliner, because I like to have colored eyeliner. I bought this with a $3.00 off coupon from Rite Aid which was absolutely amazing so it ended up being about $1.00. The color of this eyeliner is a beautiful bright green that has shimmer in it. I like the way that it looks and brings dimension since when the light hits the liner, it has a sheen. I don’t like that it doesn’t show up on a darker look, but on a lighter eye look, it looks great. So, if you are a person who wears a lot of dark shadows, smokey eyes, etc. this product may not be the best. However, that is only this eyeliner rather than any other since I have not tried it. Other than that, it works amazingly well and doesn’t smudge or wear for the many hours that I have worn it.

Positive: Works great.

Negative: Doesn’t show up on a dark shadowed look.