This is a very good beginner eyeliner. My mom had this for a long time; I have no clue if they still sell this. I really do like this though. The other end if for you to smudge the liner if you don’t want it to be so prominent, this is my second liner and I love it because the pencil is not harsh on the lid and glides on pretty smoothly if you want dragging it like you want to kill it haha. I really like the pigmentation because it is dark. I would buy this again but like I said it is probably not around anymore. Cover Girl is really good though so any eyeliner will be a good replacement of this!

Positive: glides on well.

Negative: There is fall out if you sharpen to fast because it is weak.

WTB: not sure…